| Year/Team |
Name |
| 2024 First Team |
6: Vanessa Aviles3, Emma Beddow4, Kelsey Croft, Heidi Harris, Sarah Hungerford2, Avery Williams |
| 2024 Second Team |
2: Abigail Akerson, Lizz Forshaw |
| 2023 First Team |
2: Emma Beddow3, Brooke Quimette2 |
| 2023 Second Team |
3: Carley Canzoneri5, Anna Grady4, Sage Smith |
| 2022 First Team |
6: Emma Beddow2, Sarah Hungerford, Rachael Sweigard3, Carley Canzoneri4, Maria Kilset2, Lizzie Hedrick |
| 2022 Second Team |
2: Anna Grady3, Brooke Quimette |
| 2021 First Team |
6: Vanessa Aviles2, Emma Beddow, Carley Canzoneri3, Sara Halilhodzic, Parker Morgan3, Rachel Sweigard2 |
| 2021 Second Team |
2: Anna Grady2, Maria Kilset |
| 2020 First Team |
4: Vanessa Aviles, Madeline Goodfellow4, Parker Morgan2, Maddy Peterson |
| 2020 Second Team |
5: Carley Canzoneri2, Anna Grady, Kimmy May3, Bria Riancho, Rachel Sweigard |
| 2019 First Team |
4: Carley Canzoneri, Riley Clark3, Madeline Goodfellow3, Kimmy May2 |
| 2018 First Team |
5: Riley Clark2, Madeline Goodfellow2, Olivia Jarrell4, Kimmy May, Parker Morgan |
| 2018 Second Team |
2: Michelle Lamorte, Amanda Murphy |
| 2017 First Team |
7: Tehgan Anguilm2, Riley Clark, Hugrun Elvarsdottir3, Olivia Jarrell3, Brooke Nail, Flo Spano, Cassandra Wade3 |
| 2017 Second Team |
1: Madeline Goodfellow |
| 2016 First Team |
6: Hugrun Elvarsdottir2, Mandy Janowitz, Olivia Jarrell2, Taylor Marks4, Maylyn Parsons3, Cassandra Wade2 |
| 2016 Second Team |
2: Tehgan Anguilm, Nicole Corcione4 |
| 2015 First Team |
4: Nicole Corcione3, Hugrun Elvarsdottir, Maylyn Parsons2, Shelby Rolling4 |
| 2015 Second Team |
4: Olivia Jarrell, Taylor Marks3, Chelsea Pearson2, Cassandra Wade |
| 2014 First Team |
5: Nicole Corcione2, Casey Davis, Maylyn Parsons, Kelsey Pelletier, Shelby Rolling3 |
| 2014 Second Team |
3: Andi Larese, Taylor Marks2, Chelsea Pearson |
| 2013 First Team |
1: Shelby Rolling2 |
| 2013 Second Team |
2: Nicole Corcione, Taylor Marks |
| 2012 First Team |
4: Kansas Bayly3, Kayla Brown2, Stephanie Lowery3, Mary Mancin |
| 2012 Second Team |
2: Catherin Lovin, Shelby Rolling |
| 2011 First Team |
3: Kansas Bayly2, Kayla Brown, Stephanie Lowery2 |
| 2011 Second Team |
1: Kiana Nicholson |
| 2010 First Team |
4: Kansas Bayly, Stephanie Lowery, Stephanie Parrish3, Kate Walton |
| 2010 Second Team |
3: Willi Babillis, Kim Gaughan2, Jodan McKenzie |
| 2009 First Team |
3: Gina Goforth3, Laurel McKenzie, Jill Walthall |
| 2009 Second Team |
2: Kim Gaughan, Kelly Nimmo |
| 2008 First Team |
4: Sarah Hawkins4, Kellie Myles2, Stephanie Parrish2, Monica Sanchez4 |
| 2008 Second Team |
1: Gina Goforth2 |
| 2007 |
6: Sarah Hawkins3, Megan Honig3, Hanna Ospina, Judith Ospina2, Stephanie Parrish, Monica Sanchez3 |
| 2006 |
6: Gina Goforth, Sarah Hawkins2, Megan Honig2, Judith Ospin, Monica Sanchez2, Rachel Walthall |
| 2005 |
4: Sarah Hawkins, Megan Honig, Kellie Myles, Monica Sanchez |
2 - indicates a two-time All-PBC selection
3 - indicates a three-time All-PBC selection
4 - indicates a four-time All-PBC selection
5 - indicates a five-time All-PBC selection
Note - The PBC did not denote a first or second team until the 2008 season |
